The Internal Revenue Service gives serious consideration to complaints made alleging the abuse of the tax exempt status granted to certain organizations.
When reviewing filed complaints, the IRS carefully follows special procedures designed to assure the public of the IRS’s objectivity in the treatment of tax-exempt organizations. These procedures ensure that the IRS operates in an unbiased and appropriate manner and that its compliance programs are not improperly influenced by outside intervention.
The responsibility for administering these procedures belongs to the Exempt Organizations (EO) function, which is part of the IRS’s Tax Exempt and Government Entities Operating Division.
A complaint (also called a referral) is any communication alleging that a tax-exempt organization is in potential noncompliance with the tax law. EO receives complaints from the general public, members of Congress, federal and state government agencies, as well as from other parts of the IRS.
Filing a Complaint
A referral of an exempt organization may be made by submitting Form 13909, Tax-Exempt Organization Complaint (Referral) Form, downloadable from IRS.gov.
Form 13909 and any supporting documentation may be submitted in a variety of ways. They can be sent via:
- Mail to IRS EO Classification, Mail Code 4910DAL, 1100 Commerce St., Dallas, TX 75242-1198,
- Fax to 214-413-5415, or
- Email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Submission of Form 13909 is voluntary.
Acknowledgement and Disclosure Prohibition
All referrals are sent to analysts at the EO Classifications Office in Dallas. After a referral is made, the IRS will send an acknowledgment letter to all non-IRS sources making a referral, unless it was made anonymously.
Section 6103 of the Internal Revenue Code prohibits the IRS from disclosing whether it has initiated an examination or the results of any examination. Therefore, the IRS cannot communicate with the original source of a referral beyond the acknowledgment letter.
The Review Process
Upon receipt, research is done to confirm the identity of the organization in question and once this is complete, information is entered into a database to help the IRS keep track of the progress of the review.
An experienced EO revenue agent then performs a thorough technical analysis of the allegation made on the referral. The agent uses a “reasonable belief” standard to evaluate the facts and to determine whether EO should take further action. Before taking action, the revenue agent must determine that the facts create a reasonable belief that the allegations may be true when considered fairly and in light of other reliable information.
The reviewing EO agent will decide one of the following:
- The information does not warrant further action. In this case, the agent inputs information, including rationale, into the database and closes the referral.
- The referral relates to activities that should be considered at a future date. The agent documents the database and schedules the appropriate date to re-evaluate the information.
- The referral contains characteristics that require it to be forwarded to a committee of career EO managers and agents. This committee evaluates referrals monthly — more often in some circumstances — and decides whether to proceed with an examination. The committee also applies the “reasonable belief” standard.
- The information warrants an examination of the organization. The agent documents his or her decision and the reasons for it in the database. The information item then becomes part of the examination file.
If this process results in a decision to examine an organization, the Classification Office will forward the case to a field group for assignment to a revenue agent. The revenue agent will contact the organization and schedule an appointment to begin the examination.
The Exempt Organization Examination Process Explained
The Internal Revenue Service has a variety of tools at its disposal to make certain that tax-exempt organizations comply with federal law designed to ensure they are entitled to any tax exemption they may claim.
The responsibility for administering these procedures belongs to the Exempt Organizations (EO) function, which is part of the IRS’s Tax Exempt and Government Entities (TE/GE) Operating Division.
Examinations vs. Compliance Checks
A review of a tax exempt organization falls into two broad categories: compliance checks and examinations.
The IRS conducts examinations, also known as audits, which are authorized under Section 7602 of the Internal Revenue Code. An examination is a review of a taxpayer’s books and records to determine tax liability, and may involve the questioning of third parties. For exempt organizations, an examination also determines an organization’s qualification for tax-exempt status.
EO conducts two different types of examinations: correspondence and field examinations.
A compliance check is a review to determine whether an organization is adhering to recordkeeping and information reporting requirements and is not an examination since it does not directly relate to determining a tax liability for any particular period.
Correspondence examinations are limited in scope and focus on only one or two items on a return. An EO specialist typically conducts the examination through letters and phone calls with the organization’s officers or representatives.
If the issues become complex, or if the organization does not respond to a letter or call, EO may require the officers or representatives to bring records to an IRS office. EO may also convert a correspondence examination into a field examination.
A field examination is one conducted by a revenue agent at the organization’s place of business. Generally, these audits are the most comprehensive. There are two distinct types of EO field examinations – EO Team Examination Program (TEP) and EO General Program.
- EO TEP examinations are field examinations of large, complex organizations that may require a team of specialized revenue agents, as well as coordination between IRS functions and other governmental agencies. They are often conducted using coordinated team examination approaches and procedures.
- EO General Program examinations are typically performed by individual revenue agents. They usually do not require a team of specialists.
A field examination usually begins when the revenue agent notifies the organization that its return has been selected for examination. This initial contact is by telephone or by letter to schedule an initial appointment. The organization receives Publication 1, Your Rights as a Taxpayer, with the appointment letter.
In the appointment contact, the revenue agent will typically request the following documents to begin the audit:
- Governing instruments (articles of incorporation, charter or constitution, including all amendments; and bylaws, including all amendments),
- Pamphlets, brochures, and other printed literature describing the organization’s activities,
- Copies of the organization’s Forms 990 for the years before and after the year under examination,
- For the year under examination (at a minimum):
- Minutes of meetings of the board of directors and standing committees or councils,
- All books and records of assets, liabilities, receipts and disbursements,
- Auditor’s report, if any,
- Copies of other federal tax returns filed and any related workpapers (Form 990-T for taxable income, Form 1120-POL for political activity, etc.),
- Copies of employment tax returns and any related workpapers (Forms W-2, W-3, 941, 1096, 1099).
(Note: Many of these records may also be required for a correspondence examination.)
During an opening conference with the organization’s officers or representatives, the revenue agent explains the audit plan and the reason the organization has been selected for examination. The revenue agent usually conducts a comprehensive interview and tours the organization’s facilities to gain a basic understanding of the organization’s purposes and activities.
The examination of a tax-exempt organization is multifaceted and includes a review of its operation and activities to verify the existence of an exempt purpose, as well as a review of financial records. The length of the examination will depend upon a variety of factors, such as the size of the organization, the complexity of its activities and the issues that may arise during the examination. Some audits can be completed in just a few days; others can last for a year or more.
A field examination typically concludes with a closing conference. The revenue agent will discuss the audit with the organization’s representatives, and if necessary, furnish a report explaining proposed adjustments to the organization’s returns or exempt status. If the revenue agent and the organization’s representatives disagree on the findings, the organization may request a meeting with the revenue agent’s manager to discuss the disagreement. If the manager cannot resolve the differences, the organization may pursue its case through the IRS appeals process. For additional information on the appeals process, see Publication 892, EO Appeal Procedures for Unagreed Issues.
Exempt Organizations also maintains an active compliance check program. EO specialists conduct the checks by corresponding with or telephoning exempt organization representatives. A specialist may inquire about an item on a return, determine if specific reporting requirements have been met or whether an organization’s activities are consistent with its stated tax-exempt purpose.
An officer or representative of an exempt organization may refuse to participate in a compliance check without penalty. However, EO has the option of opening a formal examination, whether or not the organization agrees to participate in a compliance check.
At the beginning of a compliance check, the specialist will inform the officer or director that the review is a compliance check and not an examination. The specialist will not ask to examine any books or records or ask questions regarding tax liabilities. The specialist may ask whether the organization understands or has questions about filing obligations for required forms. The specialist may also ask questions about the organization’s activities. If, during a compliance check, the specialist decides an examination is appropriate, he or she will notify the organization that EO is commencing an examination before asking questions related to tax liability.
Because a compliance check only reviews whether an organization is adhering to record keeping and information reporting requirements or whether an organization’s activities are consistent with its stated tax-exempt purpose and is not an examination, it is possible to have more than one compliance check for a tax year if facts and circumstances warrant. For more information, see Publication 4386, Compliance Checks.
Selecting Organizations for Examination or Compliance Checks
EO strives to ensure consistency and fairness in its examination and compliance check processes. In its annual Implementing Guidelines, which are available on the IRS website at http://www.irs.gov/charities/index.html, EO describes its proposed examination and compliance check activities for the year.
EO designs and implements comprehensive projects to address issues that carry the most non-compliance risk. To determine which organizations should be targeted, experienced specialists analyze information from Forms 990 and other sources. This analysis will usually result in the selection of a group of returns for examination or compliance check.
EO also reviews media reports and receives complaints from the general public and Congress about potential non-compliance by exempt organizations. After confirming the information, and when appropriate, these organizations may be selected for examination or to receive a compliance check. For details on how EO handles complaints about exempt organizations, see Fact Sheet 2008-13.
Regardless of the process used to select returns, EO does not presume that an organization is violating the tax laws before it begins the examination or sends a compliance check letter.
DISCLAIMER: This information is not intended to provide legal or accounting advice, or to address specific situations. Please consult with your legal or tax advisor to supplement and verify what you learn here.